Obama Unveils Power Plant GHG Limits 08/03 14:02
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Calling it a moral obligation, President Barack Obama
unveiled the final version of his plan to dramatically cut emissions from U.S.
power plants, as he warned anew that climate change will threaten future
generations if left unchecked.
Touting the plan at a White House event on Monday, Obama said the
unprecedented carbon dioxide limits are the "the single most important step"
America has ever taken to fight climate change. He warned that because the
problem is so large, if the world doesn't get it right quickly, it may become
impossible to reverse, leaving populations unable to adapt.
"There is such a thing as being too late when it comes to climate change,"
The final version of Obama's plan imposes stricter carbon dioxide limits on
states than was previously expected: a 32 percent cut by 2030, compared with
2005 levels, the White House said. Obama's proposed version last year called
only for a 30 percent cut.
It also gives states an additional two years --- until 2022 --- to comply,
yielding to complaints that the original deadline was too soon. States will
also have an additional year to submit their implementation plans to Washington.
Obama was joined in the East Room by Environmental Protection Agency
Administrator Gina McCarthy and by parents of asthma patients. The Obama
administration has sought to draw a connection between climate change and
increased respiratory illness in vulnerable populations.
"This is an especially wicked-cool moment," said McCarthy, wielding a
colloquialism from her hometown of Boston.
The pollution controls form the core of Obama's ambitious and controversial
plan to drastically reduce overall U.S. emissions, as he works to secure a
legacy on fighting global warming. Yet it will be up to Obama's successor to
implement his plan, which has attracted strong opposition from the field of
Republican presidential candidates.
Opponents announced immediately that they will sue the government, and will
ask the courts to put the rule on hold while their legal challenges play out.
Many Republican governors have said their states simply won't comply.
The Obama administration estimated the emissions limits will cost $8.4
billion annually by 2030. The actual price won't be clear until states decide
how they'll reach their targets. But energy industry advocates said the
revision makes Obama's mandate even more burdensome, costly and difficult to
Power Plant Winners and Losers
WASHINGTON (AP) -- President Barack Obama is mandating even steeper
greenhouse gas cuts from U.S. power plants than previously expected, while
granting states more time and broader options to comply.
The tweaks to Obama's unprecedented emissions limits on power plants, to be
unveiled at the White House on Monday, aim to address a bevy of concerns raised
by both environmentalist and the energy industry. The Environmental Protection
Agency received more than 4 million public comments after Obama announced the
proposed version last year, and opponents of the plan attempted unsuccessfully
to stop it in Congress and in the courts.
Some of the changes Obama is making in the final version of the plan go even
further in cutting the heat-trapping gases blamed for global warming. Other
changes delay implementation and eliminate certain options that states could
use to show they're cutting emissions, making it harder to comply.
All states are eagerly awaiting word of changes to the individual emissions
reduction targets that Washington is assigning each state. Some states will be
given a more lenient target than they were assigned under the proposed version,
while others will have tougher targets to meet. The Obama administration has
yet to disclose those state-specific targets.
A look at potential winners and losers in Obama's final plan:
To the delight of environmental groups, Obama tightened the emissions
requirements in his final plan. That means power plants will have to attain an
even lower level of carbon dioxide pollution to be in compliance. Obama's
proposal from last year set the target as a 30 percent nationwide cut by 2030,
compared to the levels in 2005. His revamped plan calls for a 32 percent cut in
the same time period.
Left unchanged is Obama's overall goal for U.S. emissions cuts from all
sources of pollution, including cars and trucks. As the U.S. commitment to a
major global climate treaty that Obama is championing, the U.S. committed to
cutting its emissions 26 percent to 28 percent by 2030, compared to 2005.
--- PROCRASTINATING STATES
Many of the complaints directed at Obama's plan over the last year centered
on the amount of time states would have to figure out how to meet their
targets. Plans for how states will comply are technically due next year, but
there's no penalty to asking for a two-year extension, so most states are
expected to delay. Under the earlier plan, the rock-bottom deadline was 2017,
but that's being pushed back to 2018.
And while states previously had until 2020 to achieve their targets, they'll
now have an extra two years --- until 2022.
--- RENEWABLE ENERGY
Obama's revised plan relies more heavily on renewable energy sources like
wind and solar replacing dirtier coal-fired power plants. Obama now wants the
U.S. to get 28 percent of its power from renewables by 2030, compared to 22
percent in his earlier proposal.
In a new element, the administration now intends to offer pollution credits
to states that drive up renewable energy generation in 2020 and 2021 ahead of
the compliance deadline. States that invest early in wind and solar can store
away those credits to offset pollution emitted after the compliance period
starts in 2022.
--- YOUR POWER BILL
Although the administration predicts the plan will actually lower the
average U.S. energy bill by almost $85 in 2030, companies that produce and
distribute electricity aren't buying it. The savings come from increased use of
wind, power and hydro plants, which operate at a cost of close to zero after
they're installed. But acquiring and constructing renewable power sources is
still very costly, making it less cost effective in many circumstances.
The National Association of Manufacturers, the American Coalition for Clean
Coal Electricity, the National Mining Association, the American Energy Alliance
and the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association all predicted the rule
would drive electricity bills up.
--- NATURAL GAS
The earlier version of Obama's plan sought to accelerate the ongoing shift
from coal-fired power to natural gas, which emits far less carbon dioxide. But
the final rule aims to keep the share of natural gas in the nation's power mix
the same as it is now.
EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy said government estimates show renewable
energy has ticked upward even since the rule was proposed last year, but that
natural gas remained an important part of the U.S. energy mix.
--- ENERGY EFFICIENCY
The tweaks eliminate an option for states to get credit for using efficiency
programs to persuade energy consumers to use less power, one of the so-called
"beyond the fence" measures to cut overall emissions that don't directly
involve how power plants are operating. Because the administration is
specifically regulating power plants under the Clean Air Act, the inclusion of
such measures in the proposal raised concerns that they'd likely be invalidated
Even so, McCarthy said U.S. energy statisticians are seeing significant and
consistent reductions in the demand for energy in the U.S. The revised power
plant rule does offer polluting credits to states that deploy energy efficiency
programs in poorer communities.